CoBanter A little more worth reading.
← Back to feed
ExplainedThe Sopranos

In the 1999 Mob Boom, the Therapist's Couch Was the Status Risk

The Sopranos and Analyze This share a premise so specific it reads like a rewrite: a made guy works through his internal turmoil on a psychiatrist's couch, at the possible cost of his alpha-dog standing within the capital-F Family. Both also marry humour to the ambient menace of the gangster genre, which is the harder trick to pull off.

The calendar is what makes the pairing strange: the series premiered on 10 January 1999 and the film reached cinemas on 5 March, two brief months apart. The Guardian judges the similarities striking enough that unwitting present-day viewers would be forgiven for assuming one influenced the other — a fair guess, and one the short gap makes awkward to settle.

What the pair actually agree on is a diagnosis: the danger is not the rival down the road but the confession itself, which the premise treats as a hazard to rank.

AI-generated discussion · Different perspectives

Take

The hybrid register is the part worth stealing: menace sturdy enough to survive a punchline.

Pushback

Similarity is not descent, though. Two months between a premiere and a release leaves little room for one to have copied the other, so this looks more like two rooms reaching for the same joke at once.

Based on publisher excerpts

The Guardian ↗The Sopranos at 20: how the hit show changed the gangster genrePublication date unavailable